Buying used cars can be a rewarding experience if you approach it with careful planning and research.
Our team evaluated the dealerships based on Google customer reviews, industry standing, quality ratings, and awards for customer service and working conditions. Our procedure for listing involves manual research, two-tier review, and placement. Whether you want to buy or sell a used car in Indianapolis, these dealers should be the first stops on your journey.
- Indy Auto Man, Indianapolis, IN
Indy Auto Man is a local Indianapolis used car dealership, established in 2008. They provide a full range of services, including buying and selling cars, maintenance, repairs, and detailing. The dealership offers an assortment of cars, trucks, SUVs, and minivans in various price ranges. Indy Auto Man also accepts trade-ins of any make and model and offers in-house financing options for those who prefer not to pay the full price upfront. For customers residing outside Indianapolis, the dealership provides online car sales with a complimentary Uber drive and delivery within 250 miles, along with trade-in field assessment and pickup. Each vehicle is accompanied by a free Carfax report, a 7-day return policy, and a 30-day price match guarantee. Indy Auto Man boasts a 4.9 rating on Google Reviews, was recognized as one of the Best Indianapolis dealerships by ThreeBestRated, and was honored as a Top Workplace in Central Indiana in 2024.
2. Car City, South Bend, Indiana
Car City has proudly been serving customers for over 23 years. From its humble beginnings in Wyoming, MI, the company has expanded to include seven locations across Michigan in Grand Rapids, Muskegon, Cadillac, Battle Creek, Lansing, Kalamazoo, as well as South Bend, Indiana, located 12 minutes from Notre Dame Stadium. The company’s guiding principles are deeply rooted in family values, focusing on providing top-notch customer service and fostering lasting relationships. Their goal is to assist individuals in finding the perfect car while offering seamless financing solutions, regardless of their credit situation. Once approved, customers gain access to a vast online inventory featuring hundreds of cars, ensuring they can find their ideal vehicle.
3. Preferred Auto Group, Fort Wayne, IN
Preferred Automotive Group was established In 1989 on Speedway Drive in Fort Wayne, Indiana, starting with just 3 employees and 6 vehicles. Over time, the company expanded to include 2 dealerships in Fort Wayne, gaining recognition for offering high-quality vehicles and earning a reputation in the local community. Among their accolades, they are particularly proud of receiving the “Business of Integrity” award from the Better Business Bureau of NE Indiana. Serving customers in Fort Wayne, they provide access to a wide range of used vehicles, including pre-owned pickups, SUVs, eco-friendly sedans, and family-friendly minivans.
4. Midwest Motors, Indianapolis, IN
Conveniently situated in Indianapolis, Midwest Motors caters to customers from the local region and beyond. The dealer has meticulously assembled an array of vehicles to accommodate a diverse spectrum of tastes and financial plans. Whether you seek an economical everyday vehicle for urban commutes or a lavish car that mirrors your refined lifestyle, they have something to offer. Their commitment lies in delivering outstanding customer service and guaranteeing a seamless, transparent, and stress-free car-buying journey. Their team of experts is dedicated to guiding customers through every stage, from perusing their stock to securing financing solutions tailored to any budget.
5. Tom Wood Automotive Group, Indianapolis, IN
Tom Wood Automotive dealerships provide an extensive selection of new and pre-owned vehicles along with certified maintenance services at their service centers. Customers can take advantage of lifetime powertrain coverage and receive a complimentary car wash with each visit to their service station. The Tom Wood Automotive Group is dedicated to green initiatives, such as reclaiming used oil from oil changes to heat their showrooms. They also have the first LEED-certified dealership in Indiana. Their facilities feature cozy lounges equipped with amenities such as complimentary Wi-Fi, snacks, coffee, and a kids’ play area.
6. Ray Skillman, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Martinsville, New Whiteland, Avon, Indiana
The Ray Skillman Auto Group serves the Plainfield, Greenwood, and Indianapolis areas, offering new, used, and certified pre-owned vehicles, favorable lease terms, and flexible auto financing. They are dedicated to ensuring customer satisfaction and a seamless car buying experience. Representing various automotive brands such as Buick, Chevrolet, Ford, Hyundai, Kia, Mitsubishi, and Mazda, the Ray Skillman Auto Group’s qualified technicians deliver high-quality services, from factory-scheduled maintenance to major repairs. The dealership collaborates with national banks and local lenders to secure attractive loan rates, regardless of the customer’s budget and credit history.
Buying used cars can be a rewarding experience if you approach it with careful planning and research.
7. Andy Mohr, Avon, Fishers, Plainfield, Indianapolis, Bloomington, IN
The Andy Mohr Automotive Group offers an extensive selection of new and used vehicles, as well as reliable service and financing options. With multiple locations and a large inventory, they are a comprehensive solution for all automotive needs. Each dealer location focuses on a specific brand, such as Honda, Toyota, GMC, Chevrolet, Buick, and Ford. The Andy Mohr Automotive Group comprises 12 dealerships and service centers, four collision centers, and one heavy-duty truck center.
8. Fishers Imports, Fishers, Indiana
Fishers Imports dealership is a family-owned business, providing quality, value, and a positive experience in the luxury pre-owned auto sales industry since 2011. They have established a higher standard for the car-buying journey by providing outstanding, non-pressure service, enabling customers to complete the entire purchasing process online or over the phone. Additionally, all their vehicles come with a 90-day warranty.
9. Unlimited Motors, Westfield, Noblesville, Elwood, Fishers, IN
Unlimited Motors is recognized for its commitment to buying and selling high-quality vehicles, ensuring customer satisfaction. The dealership offers a diverse selection of used newer models, including domestic and exotic cars, along with top-notch customer service across their facilities in Indiana. Unlimited Motors specialists apply cutting-edge tools, equipment, and technologies for inspecting and servicing the cars in their inventory. Each vehicle undergoes a road test and professional detailing, and the dealership provides various financing options and extensions for factory warranties.
10. Curry Auto Center, Bloomington, IN
Curry Auto Center is a reputed family-owned Buick, Chevrolet, and GMC dealership. They also offer pre-owned cars, SUVs, and trucks of all makes and models to choose from. The dealer provides auto loans for any budget and top-notch car service. Curry Auto Center boasts the most extensive and advanced collision center in southern Indiana.
This rating is intended to assist Indiana customers in selecting a used car dealer and purchasing high-quality used cars. To make a more informed decision, we suggest conducting additional research and starting with requesting trade-in value or getting pre-approved for a car loan. This will help assess the service and compare offers nearby to select the most favorable deal.